Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand

aus Wikipedia, der freien Enzyklopädie
Zur Navigation springen Zur Suche springen

@Masti: Thanks again for doing the stats for this year :-) There is one article Martina Lubyová that isn't counted with zero points? Do you have an idea why that could be the case? Parameters look fine, article was created on de.wp during the contest and the size also fits. Br, Braveheart Diskussion Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand#c-Braveheart-2024060115010011Beantworten

let me check --Masti (Diskussion) Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand#c-Masti-20240601175600-Braveheart-2024060115010011Beantworten
@Masti: Would be so kind to check my article Mai Kolossova with 0 points, too? Thank you! --Maimaid  Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand#c-Maimaid-20240601220800-Masti-2024060117560011Beantworten
Sure :) --Masti (Diskussion) Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand#c-Masti-20240602105300-Maimaid-2024060122080011Beantworten
@Braveheart, Maimaid: from the first check. Both articles history show creation dates in 2022. So they are treated as updated, not new articles. But the history looks little strange to me. Trying to understand it. Specially Spezial:Diff/244109033. Masti (Diskussion) Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand#c-Masti-20240602202800-Masti-2024060210530011Beantworten
@Masti:
  • The English version of the article Martina Lubyová was published in 2022 in the en-WP. The German article was published on 16 April 2024, including the imported revision history of the English version since 2022.
  • My article Mai Kolossova was published in the de-WP on 28 May 2024. I had already created the draft for this article already in 2022.
Where is the problem? In our 6 rules for this competition, I can't find any reason to give 0 points here.
I would just like to understand it. Many thanks for your effort. --Maimaid  Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand#c-Maimaid-20240602205500-Masti-2024060220280011Beantworten
@Maimaid: for Mai Kolossova the main edit the bot sees is Spezial:Diff/224266636. So it counts +1,152 bytes, in fact also next small ones, which means <2kB (Artikelverbesserung: 1 Punkt ab 300 Wörter oder 2 kB) so this is why it assigns 0 pts. It should count the whole article as it was moved into main during competition. But the data I get from Wikimedia API does not contain this info. So I am trying how I can assign proper points. That is why the whole list incl. points is published so you can verify what is counted. Masti (Diskussion) Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand#c-Masti-20240602212800-Maimaid-2024060220550011Beantworten
Thank you and good night! --Maimaid  Wikipedia Diskussion:Wikimedia CEE Spring 2024/Punktestand#c-Maimaid-20240602220200-Masti-2024060221280011Beantworten